Close this search box.
Close this search box.


We do a detailed research on all services we review in GTA.

The 8 Best Custom Cake Shops in Toronto [2023]

Got a sweet tooth for custom cakes in Toronto? Experience our top 8 cake shops, each famed for their unique, delicious, and visually stunning cake creations.

Looking for more tasty experiences in the GTA? Consider:

The 5 Best Bakeries in Brampton
The 6 Best Shawarmas in Oakville
The 5 Best Indian Restaurants In Brampton
The 5 Best Italian Restaurants in Oakville

Ready to surrender to sweetness? Visit one of the top custom cake shops in Toronto today!

1) Sweet Serendipity

Sweet Serendipity, your home-style bake shop with a wide selection of delectable cakes using the finest ingredients. Their bakeshop goodies include full-size and custom made cakes, perfect for birthdays or any other occasion. Their custom-made cakes are priced individually based on serving size and the amount of design work and size and the smallest size available is an 8-inch round. 

Business Information:

1335 Danforth Ave, Toronto

Customer Review:
“Got a carrot cake for my husband’s birthday. He and everyone who had it loved it. Quick response on emails and did what they said they would do. Very moist and delicious cake. Cream cheese frosting. I would order again.”
“Ordered my son's first birthday cake from here after reading the reviews and it was amazing! Pina worked with me on the design of the cake and she did a fantastic job. Every guest at our party said it was the best chocolate cake and I couldn't agree more! Will definitely be ordering from here in the future.”

2) Patisseh

For those with dietary restrictions, finding delicious baked goods can be a challenge. But at Patisseh, they specialize in creating custom desserts to meet every need. Whether you’re looking for something gluten-free, dairy-free, nut-free, vegan, or keto-friendly, they can help. 

All of their baked goods are made by hand using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. And because they use only the best ingredients, you can be sure that your dessert will be both delicious and beautiful. So if you’re looking for a unique and special treat, be sure to contact Patisseh.

Business Information:
Yonge and, St Clair Ave W, Toronto, ON M4T 0A5

Customer Review:
“Patisseh is my go to place for cakes and cookies. I’ve been ordering from them for years now. Always impressed with their work and turn around time. Very professional and super easy to work with. Sanya is a gem!”
“The most delicious food and treats. Obsessed with their samosas that we tried for a party they catered. I recommend Patisseh to all of my friends. As a bonus, it is run by the nicest people!|”

3) Staij & Co Café and Pastry Boutique

Staij & Company is a gourmet bakery that specializes in custom cakes and pastries. The company was founded by two friends who share a passion for baking and cooking. Their business began with wedding cakes, and they eventually expanded into the cafe business. 

Today, Staij & Company offers a wide range of baked goods, including artisanal toasts, fresh pastries, and custom cakes. their focus on utilizing great ingredients and their attention to detail results in baked goods that are both delicious and visually stunning. 

In addition to their gourmet offerings, Staij & Company also takes pride in providing an exceptional customer experience. Their friendly and knowledgeable staff is always happy to help guests choose the perfect cake or pastry for their needs.

Business Information:
 552 Parliament St, Toronto, ON M4X 1P6

4) bobbette and belle

At bobbette and belle, they believe that cake should be an experience, not just a dessert. They specialize in creating customized cakes and cupcakes that are perfect for any occasion. Using only the finest ingredients, their cakes are made from scratch and baked fresh to order. 

Their talented team of decorators can create anything you can imagine, from classic designs to modern masterpieces. And because they know that every event is unique, they offer a variety of cake customization options, including different flavors, colors, and decorations. Whether you’re planning a wedding, birthday, or any other special event, bobbette and belle will make sure your cake is unforgettable.

Business Information:
3347 Yonge St, Toronto, ON M4N 2M6

Customer Review:
“Absolutely loved the service. Lulu was great! she helped accommodate a last minute request and went out of the way to have the order prepared and delivered within 24 hours. My mother loved the carrot cake. Definitely not looking anywhere else for all future orders.”
“My go to place for Macarons! Always made fresh and a very good selection. Staff is very friendly and the interior is very charming!”

5) For the Love of Cake Custom Creations

At For the Love of Cake Custom Creations, they understand that your wedding cake is one of the most important elements of your big day. That’s why they offer a wide range of designs to choose from, so you can find the perfect cake for your event. 

Whether you’re looking for a traditional cake or something more unique and innovative, they have something to suit every taste. 

Plus, their team of talented cake decorators are skilled in creating beautiful and mouth-watering cakes that will make a lasting impression on your guests. Contact them today to learn more about their services and to find the perfect cake for your wedding.

Business Information:
171 East Liberty St. Unit 117 Toronto, ON, M6K 3P6

Customer Review:
“I ordered the best cupcakes from here! My family loved the cupcakes and the edible images on them, biggest smiles on their face seeing and eating them. Highly recommend ordering from here. (Also look how cute the storefront is, the cupcakes look to die for)”
“We got our wedding cake from this place precovid and have been getting cakes for family celebrations for over 4 years now. The team has followed all the little instructions and are very helpful in making recommendations. I love their vanilla and strawberry flavour and can't wait for spring to order my personal box of strawberry shortcake cupcakes!”

6) Velvet Lane Cakes

If you’re looking for a truly unique and delicious dessert, look no further than Velvet Lane Cakes. Their team of skilled cake artists create stunning and delicious cakes that are perfect for any occasion. Whether you’re looking for a custom designed cake or one of their signature creations, you’re sure to be impressed. 

And because they only use the freshest ingredients, you can be confident that your cake will taste as good as it looks. So next time you need a special treat, be sure to give Velvet Lane Cakes a call. You won’t be disappointed.

Business Information:
194 Carlton Street, Toronto ON. M5A 2K8

Customer Review:
“Been using velvet lane cakes for years for every celebration in my life. They always exceed my expectations. Would definitely recommend them, they are very professional. The cakes just don't look amazing they taste amazing too! just a couple of my faves ive ordered.”
“I had ordered a custom Nike cake for my spouse and it was a little last minute. However they did an amazing job. The cake was exactly like the pictures and flavours were amazing. A big thank you and best wishes. Highly recommended.”

7) Serano Bakery

Serano Bakery is a family-owned business that takes pride in offering only the best products, carefully prepared using natural ingredients. As such, they have the largest array of Greek pastries, breads, and custom cakes. 

They also have an impressive Greek food market with a large selection of imported Greek cheeses, authentic Greek yogurt, coffee, olive oil, mountain tea, canned goods like Dolmades, and frozen calamari from the Mediterranean Sea. 

All of these ingredients come together to create a culinary experience that is truly second to none. And because they use only the freshest ingredients, you can be sure that their products are of the highest quality.

Business Information:
830 Pape Ave, East York, ON M4K 3T5

Customer Review:
“Wonderful bakery with lots of different kinds of sweets and other items. Pretty big store and staff working were very helpful. Great place to buy some cakes or other desserts for celebration.”
“Their pastries are so yummy. Love the variety of freshly baked treats and you can even get mini pastries to try different flavours. I must say their service was really good. Want to go back there every week.”

8) The CakeSmith Inc.

The next time you’re looking for a truly unique dessert, look no further than The Cake Smith. They specialize in custom cakes made to order, so you can be sure your cake will be one of a kind. Not only do they have all of the traditional flavors and ingredients you love, but they also offer a wide variety of unique flavor combinations that are sure to delight even the most discerning palate. 

And if you’re not sure what you want, their talented team of cake designers will work with you to create a custom cake that is sure to impress. So whether you’re looking for something classic or something truly unique, The Cake Smith is the perfect place to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Business Information:
2352 Bloor St. West, Toronto, ON M6S 1P3

Customer Review:
“So delicious cakes and pastries. Very friendly customer service. I highly recommend this place and everyone need to try their pastries. My favourite thing are hazelnut cake, cake pops and chocolate raspberry mousse.”
“I really like to go to this bakery, their cakes are a pleasure for the soul! I also ordered a cake for the birthday of my son "Napoleon" - now it's his favorite! Highly recommend!”
FAQs about Custom Cakes

The cost of custom cakes can vary wildly based on the size, design, and ingredients of the cake. However, on average, a custom cake in Toronto will cost between $50 and $150. If you’re looking for a more affordable option, you can often find premade cakes that are similar in price to custom cakes.

Here are a few of the more popular types of custom cakes: wedding cakes, birthday cakes, baby shower cakes, and anniversary cakes. 

It will depend on the complexity and size of the cake. However, a good rule of thumb is that it can take anywhere from one hour to several hours to create a custom cake. Some factors that will impact how long it takes to create a custom cake include the complexity of the design. 

The most common type of frosting is buttercream, which is made from butter, sugar, and eggs. Other popular types of frosting include cream cheese frosting, ganache, and Swiss meringue buttercream.


Trying to decide what kind of cake to get for your upcoming event? Why not try something custom from one of Toronto’s amazing cake shops? No matter what the occasion, you’re sure to find the perfect cake to suit your needs. Got a big birthday party coming up? Consider a tiered cake with all your favourite flavours. Or maybe you’re looking for something a little more unique? 

Many shops offer custom cakes that are truly one-of-a-kind. Whatever you’re looking for, you’re sure to find it at one of these wonderful bakeries. So next time you need a cake, be sure to check out one of these businesses! You won’t be disappointed.